Skip to product information
Three packages of Point Reyes Bay Blue Rustic Style Blue Cheese on a white background
Bay Blue award winner on board
Bay Blue
Grilled peaches with melted Bay Blue cheese on top
Hands opening up a wheel of Bay Blue cheese
Point Reyes Bay Blue rustic style blue cheese packaging on a white background
Three packages of Point Reyes Bay Blue Rustic Style Blue Cheese on a white background
Bay Blue award winner on board
Bay Blue
Grilled peaches with melted Bay Blue cheese on top
Hands opening up a wheel of Bay Blue cheese
Point Reyes Bay Blue rustic style blue cheese packaging on a white background

Bay Blue

Sale price $45.00
Size: Three Bay Blue Wedges (5oz each)

Inspired by the sheer natural beauty of our coastal climate and locale, Bay Blue is a rustic-style blue cheese with a natural rind. It is known for its mellow flavor and sweet, salted caramel finish.

  • Fudge-like texture with a beautiful natural rind
  • Mild blue mold pungency
  • Earthy with notes of malty toasted grain
  • Sweet, salted caramel finish

The star of an after-dinner cheese course, Bay Blue is perfect for savoring alongside a glass of Vintage Port or Barrel-Aged Scotch. In the kitchen, the options are endless. Bay Blue is a great topper for a succulent steak or burger, shaved onto poached pears or grilled peaches or melted into mushroom risotto. Wine suggestions include a Chenin Blanc or an earthy Pinot Noir.

  • 2026 World Cheese Awards, Bronze
  • 2025 California State Fair, Double Gold
  • 2024 American Cheese Society, 3rd Place
  • 2024 International Cheese & Dairy Awards, Bronze
  • 2024 Good Food Awards
  • 2024 World Cheese Championship, Gold/Best of Class
  • 2024 California State Fair, Gold
  • 2023 California State Fair Cheese Competition, Silver
  • 2023 US Championship Cheese, 1st Place/Best of Class
  • 2022 California State Fair, Best of Show
  • 2022 World Cheese Awards - Bronze
  • 2022 American Cheese Society, 3rd Place
  • 2019 California State Fair, Gold
  • 2019 American Cheese Society, 1st Place
  • 2018 California State Fair, Silver
  • 2018 Good Food Awards, Best Cheese
  • 2017 World Cheese Awards - Gold
  • 2018 CA State Fair, Gold/Best of California/Best of Show
  • 2017 American Cheese Society, 3rd Place
  • 2017 California State Fair - Best Cheese of the Year
  • 2016 California State Fair, Gold/Best of California/Best of Show
  • 2015 Specialty Food Association sofi™ Award, Outstanding Cheese
  • 2018 Clifornia State Fair, Silver
  • 2014 American Cheese Society, 2nd Place, Best of Show
  • 2014 American Cheese Society, 1st Place Blue Veined Category
  • 2014 World Cheese Championship - 3rd place
  • 2014 World Cheese Awards, 3rd Place
  • 2013 American Cheese Society, 3rd Place
  • 2013 Specialty Food Association Sofi™ Award, Best New Product
  • 2013 Good Food Awards, Best Cheese
  • 2013 US Cheese Championship Awards - 3rd place
  • 2012 American Cheese Society, 3rd Place
Made from pasteurized, rBST-free cows’ milk
Aged for 90 Days
Gluten Free
Made with microbial (vegetarian) rennet
Halal Certified

Comparing our blue cheeses

A blue cheese for every occasion. 

3 Point Reyes Original Blue wedges sitting on the bottom
Original Blue
Three packages of Point Reyes Bay Blue Rustic Style Blue Cheese on a white background
Bay Blue
Three packages of Point Reyes Fennel Blue cheese on a transparent background
Fennel Blue
Flavor
Bright and milky with a bold peppery finish 
Earthy and malty, brioche bread with a sweet, salted-caramel finish 
Mellow yet complex with an aromatic hint of licorice sweetness in the finish 
Texture
Ultra creamy, buttery
Fudgy with velvety creaminess
Fudgy with satisfying chewiness from the fennel seeds 
Age
60+ Days
50+ Days
50+ Days
Rind
Rindless
Natural
Natural
Milk
Raw
Pasteurized
Pasteurized

Shipping and ordering

Still have questions? We're here to help Monday through Friday 8am to 4pm PST. 

Contact Us

The short answer is whenever you want! 

During the checkout process, you will be prompted to select a requested delivery date*, Tuesday – Friday, up to 60 days in the future. This is perfect for shopping ahead of time for holidays, birthdays, or special occasions. 

We ship via FedEx Express service. Most orders arrive on the target date, but sometimes it may arrive a day early or take an extra day to arrive. If you're planning a party, choose a day or two
early to be safe. 

Important Notes for all Shipments: 

 - We ship via FedEx Express Service, Monday – Wednesday with enough frozen gel ice to 2-3 days of transit time in case there are delays- Once your order ships you will receive an email with your FedEx tracking information. 

- Click here for more shipping details. 


* Requested delivery dates may not be available for all products.

 

We ship exclusively via FedEx Express Service.

We charge a flat rate of $20 per package within the contiguous United
States.  Shipments to Alaska and Hawaii are a flat rate of $35 per package.


If ordering multiple items/gift packs and more than a $20 charge is assessed on your bill it is because we have determined that your multiple-item order cannot ship in one package. 

Due to the perishable nature of our products, we are unable to ship to a PO Box. When checking out, please provide physical shipping addresses only.

Yes! To send gifts to multiple addresses, please visit our Corporate and Volume Gifting page. From there, you can easily send gifts directly to multiple recipients or choose E-Gifting and let your recipients provide their own shipping information.

Please note that multiple-address orders must be placed through our Corporate and Volume Gifting page rather than through our regular online store.

Bay Blue recipes

Loved by chefs, made for your kitchen. Explore recipes with Bay Blue.

View All Recipes
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
View All Recipes